A return decision is an administrative order requiring a third-country national — someone who is not a citizen of the EU or EEA — to leave the territory of the European Union.
This legal tool is commonly issued when an individual has overstayed their visa, been denied a residence permit, or otherwise lost the right to remain.
In the Netherlands, multiple authorities have the power to issue a return decision. These include the Immigration and Naturalisation Service (IND), the Alien Police, and the Royal Netherlands Marechaussee (Koninklijke Marechaussee). Return decisions typically fall into two categories:
-
A voluntary departure order, which gives the individual a specific timeframe — usually 28 days — to leave the Netherlands and the EU.
-
An immediate departure order, which requires the person to exit the EU without delay.
It is essential to understand that a return decision is not the same as an entry ban. While a return decision demands departure, an entry ban actively prohibits re-entry into the Schengen Area for a set period.
New Policy from 7 March 2023: Return Decisions in the SIS
As of 7 March 2023, the IND has implemented a new policy whereby return decisions are now recorded in the Schengen Information System (SIS) as “alerts on return.” This update aligns the Netherlands with EU regulations that aim to enhance cooperation and enforcement across Schengen borders.
The SIS is a shared security and information database used by Schengen countries to monitor persons and objects of interest — including individuals who are subject to return decisions. Once a return alert is entered into the system, it becomes visible to border and immigration authorities across the entire Schengen Area.
This means that if your name is registered under an alert on return in SIS, any attempt to cross an external Schengen border will trigger the alert. This can result in denied entry, secondary checks, or enforcement of the return order.
If you have received a return decision or suspect that your data is registered in SIS, it is highly advisable to consult an immigration lawyer. A legal expert can assess your case, explain your rights, and help you appeal or resolve unjust alerts that could otherwise impact your mobility across Europe. Consider scheduling a consultation.
When Does a Foreigner Receive a Return Decision in the Netherlands?
Foreign nationals may receive a return decision from Dutch immigration authorities under various circumstances — all of which relate to a loss or lack of legal residence rights in the Netherlands or the broader Schengen Area. A return decision is a formal notice requiring the individual to leave the EU territory and can have far-reaching consequences, especially once registered in the Schengen Information System (SIS).
Common Situations Leading to a Return Decision
There are several common scenarios in which a return decision may be issued:
-
The Immigration and Naturalisation Service (IND) denies your application for a residence permit.
-
The IND revokes an existing residence permit.
-
The Royal Netherlands Marechaussee (Border Police) detects that an individual has overstayed their visa while exiting the Schengen Area, such as at Amsterdam Schiphol Airport.
-
The Dutch Alien Police find that an individual is unlawfully residing in the Netherlands without a valid residence permit.
These situations can result not only in a return decision but also in a SIS alert that triggers consequences across the Schengen Zone.
Real-Life Case: Residence Permit Revoked While Abroad
Take Marc, an international student from Australia, as an example. He entered the Netherlands on a student visa to participate in an academic exchange program. Once the program ended, the university informed the IND, which then revoked Marc’s residence permit. While Marc was travelling in Turkey, unaware of the revocation, the IND issued a return decision and entered it as a SIS alert.
When Marc later attempted to enter Greece, he was stopped by border authorities who had detected the SIS alert. He was interrogated, denied entry, and returned to Turkey. It took weeks of coordinated legal intervention for the return decision to be lifted, allowing Marc to return to the Netherlands safely.
Real-Life Case: Entry Denied During Pending Appeal
Adam, a British national, applied for a self-employment residence permit in the Netherlands. The IND rejected his application and issued a return decision, registering it in the SIS. Adam promptly filed a legal objection (bezwaar), which meant — according to Dutch immigration law — that he retained legal stay during the review process.
Confident in his legal position and exempt from visa requirements as a British citizen, Adam left the Netherlands for a business trip without applying for a return visa. However, upon his return to Schiphol Airport, he was denied entry due to the active SIS alert and deported. It required extensive legal effort to convince the IND to lift the return decision. Eventually, Adam was able to return to the Netherlands and resume his activities.
These cases illustrate how return decisions — particularly once entered into SIS — can have immediate and disruptive consequences, even for those who believe they are legally in compliance. If you find yourself in a similar situation, it is essential to consult an immigration lawyer as early as possible. Legal representation can make a critical difference in appealing unjust decisions, removing SIS alerts, and protecting your rights to travel and reside in the EU.
You may find value in studying: SIS II France – How to Check and Remove a Schengen Entry Ban in 2025.
Re-Entering the Netherlands with a Return Visa: SIS Alert Risks After IND Decisions
For foreign nationals trying to re-enter the Netherlands after receiving a return decision, unexpected legal hurdles may arise—even if you possess a valid return visa. This is especially true since the Dutch Immigration and Naturalisation Service (IND) began systematically registering return decisions in the Schengen Information System (SIS) after March 7, 2023.
Case Study: Helen’s Return to the Netherlands via Schiphol
Helen, a highly skilled professional from Africa, had filed a new residence permit application and was granted a return visa to briefly travel back to her home country. While she was abroad, the IND rejected her pending application and issued a return decision, which was immediately entered into the SIS database as an alert.
Originally planning to return to the Schengen Area through Rome’s Fiumicino Airport, Helen instead followed legal advice and flew directly to Amsterdam Schiphol. Upon arrival, Dutch Royal Border Police detained her for secondary screening, during which she was held for approximately two hours. Despite the presence of a SIS alert, she was ultimately allowed to enter the Netherlands, as her legal right of stay during the appeal process (bezwaar) was still in effect.
Are These Border Measures Legal?
The legal framework offers clear guidance on how SIS alerts on return should be handled. According to Article 8 of EU Regulation 2018/1860, when a third-country national with a return decision (but without an accompanying entry ban) attempts to enter the Schengen Area:
“The executing Member State shall immediately inform the issuing Member State through the exchange of supplementary information, in order that the issuing Member State delete the alert on return without delay.”
You may find value in studying: Remove SIS Alert or Entry Ban in Hungary | Immigration Lawyer Help.
In theory, the presence of a SIS alert related solely to a return decision should not justify denying re-entry, particularly when no entry ban has been imposed. Instead, the responsible Member State should be informed and the alert promptly deleted. In practice, however, border authorities tend to deny entry when a SIS alert is flagged—regardless of whether the foreigner still possesses a valid visa or residence permit or is legally appealing an IND decision.
Risks of SIS Alerts After March 2023
If you received a negative decision from the IND on or after March 7, 2023, there is a strong possibility that your return decision was entered into the SIS. This can create serious complications at Schengen borders — even if:
-
You hold a valid Schengen visa
-
You have a return visa
-
Your residence permit is still valid
-
You are in the process of appealing a decision (e.g., submitted a bezwaar)
The presence of the SIS alert can result in denied boarding, entry refusals, or detentions at the border.
What You Should Do
If you are currently outside the EU and suspect or know that you have a SIS return alert, it is essential to act quickly. A lawyer can request the IND to delete the return decision and the related SIS alert, especially if you are still in the appeal window or possess legal grounds for continued stay.
If your residence permit or visa has expired, or you’ve received a negative IND decision, seek professional legal assistance before attempting to re-enter the Netherlands. Legal experts can:
-
Check the existence and status of SIS alerts.
-
Contact the IND to request removal of the return alert.
-
Support your legal right to re-entry based on ongoing proceedings.
When facing complex immigration issues in the Netherlands, don’t take chances at the border. A strategic legal approach can protect your rights and prevent unnecessary refusals or legal entanglements.
Let us protect your right to freedom of movement. Contact us today for a personalized consultation.